Le Lude Left Me Feeling Flat
Experience 3.0 Franschhoek Wine 3.5

Le Lude Left Me Feeling Flat

Friday 5 July 2019

Dr Peter Rating – Experience: 3/5
Dr Peter Rating –
Wines: 3.5/5

Held up by slow traffic, I played my own car game to pass the time. It was much more fun that the ones my parents used to give my sister and me when we were bored on a long journey. It was a car wine game! How many estates have I visited and reviewed along the R45 between the N1 highway and Franschhoek? I counted an impressive 19 from successive days out from Cape Town together with a fabulous Franschhoek weekend that included a day on the Wine Tram: Anura, Glen Carlou, Backsberg, Babylonstoren, Noble Hill, Vrede en Lust, Plaisir de Merle, Allée Bleu, Boschendal, Solms-Delta, Anthonij Rupert, Paserene, Le Manoir de BrendelLa Motte, Môreson, Leopard’s Leap, Maison, Rickety Bridge and Grande Provence. It would have been 20 except that La Chataigne is no longer open. Mental note to self: visit Rupert & Rothschild, Eikenhof and Four Paws Wines to gain the full house.

Le Lude

Franschhoek was resplendent in the winter sunshine and bedecked with red, white and blue flags ahead of the forthcoming Bastille Wine Festival. I was pleased to have avoided this hectic weekend, famed for drinking more than tasting. I nearly did not make it to Le Lude as there was a barrier on the road to say it was closed due to last week’s rock fall in the Franschhoek Pass after recent, albeit very welcome, winter rains. Fortunately, the road was closed further up the Valley and so I entered the unassuming, damp sandy road leading to the Le Lude Tasting Room. I was expecting great things having read the current media excitement that Decanter had awarded Le Lude the highest ever points for a South African MCC at the 2019 World Wine Awards, gaining 97 Points and a Platinum Award in the annual competition.

Le Lude

I parked beside the Orangerie Restaurant and Tasting Room building unsure where to go. The surrounding mountains of the Hawekwa Nature Reserve were crystal clear above the unpruned winter vines. The Wine Tram pulled up shortly after I arrived which hurried my way into the Tasting Room where I was transported into a little piece of France. Accordion music was gently playing in the large classic panelled room with cut glass chandeliers and gilt-edged mirrors decked out in duck egg blue paintwork. Each table had three wide tulip glasses neatly set out for the taster. The Restaurant stretched out into the bright conservatory with crisp white linen laid out on circular tables.

Le Lude

Le Lude

I was offered 2 tastings: two Non Vintage MCC for R90 or three MCC for R210, to include the Vintage Cuvée wine. Selected canapé selections were a further R100. I never mind paying for MCC tasting as the wines clearly do not last as long as a table wine but R210 for 3 glasses was beyond my budget. The Brut and Brut Rosé are both non vintage, cost R290, made using only cuvée (free run) juice, and aged for 36 months on the lees and 6 months in the bottle before release. The Brut wine is Chardonnay-led (54%) whilst the Brut Rosé has more Pinot Noir (65%). I rated both the same with their fine rising bubbles in the glass that gave a good moussante mouthfeel.

Le Lude

Le Lude

The fruit character of the 2 wines was very different. The aromas and flavours were decidedly shy on both and this was not due to the wines being over-chilled. I struggled to pick out faint lemon, lime and yeasty notes on the Brut MCC whilst the Brut Rosé was less yeasty with fruitier Pinot Noir flavours of light strawberry. It was good to taste them together. Shortly after pouring, the lighting failed in the Tasting Room but I was able to decant to the Orangerie. The staff were prompt in lighting candles to give a romantic, subdued feel to the room.

Le Lude

Le Lude

Much to my surprise I learned nothing about Le Lude or even its superb Platinum Decanter award (which I knew of beforehand and researched after) even though I introduced myself as a wine enthusiast and was not chasing the next tram. The boutique MCC winery is owned by attorney Nic and wife Ferda Barlow. The 6 hectare property has just 3 hectares of Chardonnay, Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier vines with the first harvest made in 2012. Le Lude is the first (I am unsure if only) South African winery to use the little known, artisanal Agrafè (Tirage Liège) Méthode of MCC production. The word ‘agrafè’ is believed to derive from the Old French verb ‘agraffer’ which means ‘to seize with a grappling hook, attach with a clasp’. Secondary fermentation in the bottle is generally undergone under a crown cork but this old/new method uses a special cork with a wire cage called an agrafè. Think of a cork Grolsch beer stopper. The technique is said to give the MCC a more integrated aroma profile, a more developed and multi-layered mouthfeel, and nuanced texture. It would have been good to compare but perhaps none was available.

Le Lude

Le Lude

The agrafè wines and method were never mentioned during the tasting which was unfortunate. I would have loved to have learned more about the method or even given the opportunity to taste and compare. I asked to chat with the Tasting Room Manager before leaving to ask about and to explain the Cape Wine Lovers’ Society as well as the tasting. He emerged with characteristic French brusqueness as if I was a nuisance to him and as if I was ready to complain – even though by now the candles were well sorted albeit the power was not yet resumed – so I hardly bothered. All in all, Le Lude left me feeling rather flat. It seems too from feedback to this review that I am not alone with this lack of sparkle.

#capewinelover #DrPeter

Wines tasted (bought *):


NV Brut MCC – R290

Le Lude

You Might Also Like

Bramon Beside the (Plettenberg) Bay

Slave to the Rhythm at Solms-Delta

Four Partners (not Cousins) at the Vineyard Hotel

Value for Money at Van Zylshof

Bushmanspad Gave Me the Weirdest Tasting Ever

Colmant Sparkled

Rickety Tram Passengers at Rickety Bridge

Peter Falke Didn’t Knock my Socks Off

Hand at Work Handiwork at Boschrivier Wines


Sublime Sauvignon Blanc Makes up for Variable Bloemendal

Bon Courage and Bon Voyage

Dornier Disappoints

Franschhoek’s Hidden Gem Is Reluctant to Reveal

“Swimming Pool” Wines for Now – or Leave until Later

Hope Lies High in the Valley

Summer Whites …… and Rosés

Never too Early in the Morning for Wine Tasting!

Quantity over Quality at Durbanville Hills

More Plaisir at de Merle Please!

Noble Wines without the Rot

Superb Views of Guardian Peak

Quality Abounds on the Mound at La Motte

Wine on the Slopes at Chamonix

Leaping to the Right Conclusions

Wagons to the Cellar at Waboomsrivier

Tasting Vines at the Vineyard

More-ish Wines at Môreson

Cabernet Franc – Well Worth a Gamble!

Old Oaks at La Bourgogne

Next Time to Taste at Hannay

Only One JC Le Roux Wine Sparkled and Scintilla-ted

Vrede en Lust Struggled to Reveal it’s Delight

Libby Would not have been Proud of Linton Park

Proudly Keeping it in the Family at Paul Cluver – or Not?

Allez les Boks – Pas les Bleues!

Boutique de Brendel

A Myth, a Princess, History and Destruction, 2 Names and 4 Styles – Shiraz with Pizzazz

Intriguing and Confusing – An Enigmatic Experience

A Kleine Experience at Zalze

Laibach Shows its Spots

Pinotage Hits a Purple Patch in Paarl

Com-fort-able Wines at Fort Simon

A Quando-ary: When to Drink …?

Intimate, Tranquil and Refined

Busy, Bubbly, Noisy Wonderfontein

The Cut ‘n’ Paste Stellenbosch Wine Festival Comes to Cape Town

Family Fun in Pairs at Four Cousins

The Vineyard Hotel a Classic Vehicle to Showcase L’Ormarins Wines

Eq-wine – Fine Wines and Fast Horses!

Haven Rather than Heaven at La Bri

Swallowing Fine Wines at Paserene

Pick n Taste Time at Stellenbosch

Where’s the Grande in Provence?

iWine rather than IMAX at the Cape Gate Mall

House Wine from the Wine Tram

Kept Alone at Kaapzicht

An Early Start at Rietvallei

Hope Brought to the Vineyard

One Day, Three Tastings, Five Wines and Seven Sisters

Tram-Way to Heaven in Franschhoek

A Lekker Jol at Wandsbeck

Try as I Could I Did not Find Waterkloof Wines Dynamic

Purring at the Wines in Tyger Valley

Robertson – Town by Name, Wine by Name

There’s No Gun Smoke Without Wine

Horsepower in the Vineyard

View from the E-Skaap-ment

Bracing Brakes on the Red Wines at Remhoogte

Lovane Serves its Guests Well

Good Things Come in Twos – at Southern Right too!

Honest, Affordable Family Wines at Landskroon

Wine Dinners are Not For Me


Style or Substance? Nitida left Me Wondering

Decent Wines Rock from the Pulpit

2018 Wacky Wine Ends at Le Roux & Fourie

Becoming Ship-Shape at La Couronne

Oh-MG at Anthonij Rupert

Surprisingly Good – and Not Only for the Red Bus Tourists

Woody Wildekrans

Wonderful Grapes at the Vineyard Hotel

Graham Beck MCCs Fizzled Out

Langverwacht Introduced Me to Ruby Cabernet

Sylvan Vale Wines Good for a Meeting or an Eating


  1. Colmant Sparkled – Cape Wine Lovers' Society

    […] planned, arriving just at the 11.00am opening time (weekday closing at 1.00pm). I had come from Le Lude that is just 1 kilometre away and so Colmant was to be my second sparkling wine tasting of the day. […]

  2. Becoming Ship-Shape at La Couronne – Cape Wine Lovers' Society

    […] Couronne was the final tasting of my day out to Franschhoek after tasting visits to Le Lude, Colmant, La Bourgogne and Haut Espoir. The wineries are all close to each other, barely 2 […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *