Marching into France
Education Experience 4.5 Wine Courses

Marching into France

Saturday 16 September 2017

Experience: 4.5/5

I remembered my assignment. I forgot my wine glasses. This was the first Cape Wine Academy assignment that I had to hand in. There is one for every Module lecture day now. It was back at Morgenhof again. It was another early morning trip. The same route South on the R44 towards Stellenbosch and past the big name estates. Dave March was the lecturer. He lectured during my Certificate Course. There was a reassuring familiarity to the start of the day. The same classroom in the church like building. Good too to meet up with other student friends before the first lecture.

Mogrenhof Cape Wine Academy

And so it was into Lecture 4 that was all about Trends in Winemaking. Even that was a familiar subject, though not for long. Dave is a Brit like me. His knowledge is enormous. Ask him any obscure question and you will get a detailed and considered answer. He is not without opinion and can be robust in his views – some might even say ‘linear’. It was not long before Dave was advising how to write assignments – Lizette had given few clues on the first day of lectures – and I had only just handed my assignment in. Dave was marking them too. It was too late now for advice! Do not rely on the Course notes, Dave espoused. Fortunately, I had not and relied on my knowledge and internet searches. Only after, I saw there was material in the massive folder that I could have used.

Cape Wine Academy

I digress. But then Dave likes to digress too. The content of the first lecture was much the same as I had heard during the Certificate Course. There was just a huge lot more to know. Dave covered alcoholic fermentation; malolactic fermentation; the components of wine – acid and acidity, alcohol, phenolic compounds; winemaking procedures and materials; and spoiled and faulty wines. The lecture notes seemed incidental but were not. They are the raw ingredients for when I take the Theory exam.

Cape Wine Academy

Cape Wine Academy

Cape Wine Academy

The first flight of 4 red wines was poured: 2 Merlot and 2 Pinotage, but in different styles. It was interesting to hear another lecturer talk about how to taste and assess. Lizette had told us barely to bother with colour at Diploma level. Dave was using colour. Pinot Noir and Merlot are garnet-based reds; Cabernet Sauvignon and Shiraz in the ruby-red family; and, if unsure, it is likely to be Pinotage in between. I had barely stopped in recent tastings to consider the garnet red end of the colour spectrum and so I must look again.

Cape Wine Academy

More lecture and then another flight of wines, this time 3 white wines. Dave explained how to write a blind tasting note for the exam using a Chenin Blanc from Nederburg. ‘Depth-colour-intensity-acidity’, ‘Depth-colour-intensity-acidity’, ‘Depth-colour-intensity-acidity’. These are the key identifier clues. I need get this mantra firm into my head. It is as important too to ‘rule out’ as it is to ‘rule in’ when considering a grape variety or country.

Cape Wine Academy

The Chenin Blanc was to allow me to calibrate my tasting radar. The next 2 wines were the same variety but from different countries’. But which and from where and, more importantly, why? The 2 wines seemed the same to me in appearance and body, acidity too. The second had more acidity but I could not detect much difference between them. The first was a Vouvray from France (a Chenin Blanc) and the second from the Cederberg. The Vouvray did not have ‘bristling acidity’ which indicated France. The Cederberg wine most likely had added acid, because of the cool climate, which served to confuse me. No wonder!

Cape Wine Academy

Morning coffee break could not come fast enough. It was all too short and Dave soon had the class back in the classroom. Lecture 5 was about the French Appellation System wine and wines of the Alsace. This was the first move away to the wines of another country in detail. If ever there was scope to confuse then this was it. One confusing system of classification is bad enough. I more-or-less knew the Vin de Table, Vin de Pay, VDQS and AOC/AC system from my experience of French wines in England before coming to South Africa in 2010. But all changed in 2012. The EU, having decided to treat ‘wine as food’, introduced the same regional and area classification. France, Italy and the other European wine making countries rebelled. What was the outcome? A classic EU compromise: label using both classification systems!

Cape Wine Academy

Fortunately, some very fine French wines followed for tasting. These had been picked to show the different quality. Both were Bordeaux blends. The French classification system then became worse! There is a Bordeaux system that was introduced in 1855 so visitors to the Paris Exhibition could know which wines were the best quality. Wines were ranked according to vineyard reputation and price – Premiers Crus, Deuxiemès Crus and so forth for 5 Crus. Just to confuse, one of the top 5 did not come from Médoc but from Graves. Oh, and to confuse further, white wines of the Gironde used a very similar but different system! Moreover, what once measured quality is no longer a guarantee of quality …

The first wine, of lower classification, was a Château Potensac Médoc. The other was a Grand Crus Classé Château Durfort-Vivens from Margaux. It was a 2005 vintage too which is one of the best of the 21st Century. Both wines seemed of high quality to me though the Margaux had better depth, persistence and opening.

Cape Wine Academy

Cape Wine Academy

I was please to leave the insanely complex system of French wine classification – I have simplified here – and to move to wines of the Alsace. Not so easy here though! The region has been within France and German several times throughout history and so both influences manifest. I shall skip the detail here. Just think Alsace and think Riesling (Gewürztraminer too but more after). Our last but one flight contained 3 Riesling from 3 different countries. The big Riesling producer countries are France, Germany, South Africa and Australia. Which was the one left out? I learned that the Alsace Riesling are of good quality and with a boldness of depth; the Australian ones have a characteristic lime aroma; South African ones – well I am familiar with: lots of terpenes – and Germany, sweeter and with lower alcohol (7% to 8%).

Cape Wine Academy

My mind was such a blur from the lectures (thankfully, only 2 for Day 2 and Day 3 of the Module 1 Course) that I did little than enjoy the wines and record their differences. Quickly, and somewhat rushed at the end of the morning, I tasted 2 Gewürztraminer, one from Alsace, France and one from South Africa. They served as a reminder of differences between Old World and New World wines. The Alsace wine was shy yet off-dry with some sweetness and ripeness compared with the overt, dry spritzy feel of the South African wine.

Cape Wine Academy

Cape Wine Academy

Phew! The second (of 3) Module 1 days was as exhausting – and exhaustive – as the first even though there were 2 and not 3 lectures. It was not because of Dave, who is a highly competent and knowledgeable lecturer, but because of the breadth and complexity of the content material. It reminds, if ever I needed reminding, just how much of a step up Diploma is from Certificate level. I know I shall succeed and learn but I know too that much effort will be required. Meanwhile, I must make sure I do not leave completing my assignment until the day before the final day of Module 1 …

Wines tasted:


2015 Nederburg The Anchorman Chenin Blanc (South Africa)
2015 Marc Brédit Vouvray (Chenin Blanc)(France)
2016 Cederberg Chenin Blanc (South Africa)
2005 Domaines Schlumberger Alsace (Grand Cru Riesling)(France)
2012 Nottage Hill Riesling (Australia)
2012 De Wetshof Riesling (South Africa)
2016 Neethlingshof Gewürztraminer (South Africa)
2010 Domaines Schlumberger Les Princes Abbés Alsace (France)


2015 Bellingham Mocha Java Merlot (South Africa)
2014 Jordan Black Magic Merlot (South Africa)
2015 Darling Cellars Chocoholic Pinotage (South Africa)
2015 Bellingham Pinotage (South Africa)
2009 Château Potensac Médoc (France)
2005 Grand Crus Classé Château Durfort-Vivens Margaux (France)

Cape Wine Academy

You Might Also Like

Ruddy Red and Blanc Sauvignons

Little Did I Know What I Had Started – A New Passion

How to Taste Wine©

Grand Wines at the Big Top!

Linga-ring in a Winery in Malawi

Taint, Mould, Sweet-Sour, Elastoplast, Stale Honey, Bee Wax and Potato Skin With the Wine Prof

I-own-a Wine Farm!

Red, Red (Spanish) Wine

Oh-MG at Anthonij Rupert

Well and Truly Oaked!

Hearty Food and Wine Brought by the Stork at Hartenberg

A Family Occasion – the Story behind the Bottle

From South Africa to a Whole New (and Old) World


Au Revoir France!

Classy, Small and Precious Kleinood

Cork and Talk with Dave

Idiom Puts on a Festival Master Class

Hazendal Fit for a Tsar, a Hare and a God of Wine

Brut Force and Less Ignorance

Where Eagles Care

Anysbos a Wine Estate to Look Out For

Elgin Valley is the Cool Wine Tour

King Chenin Kens (Knows) the Wood from the Trees

Of Female Rugby Players and Ballet Dancers! Let’s Continuously Study Very Seriously: Wines of the Loire and Northern Rhône

It’s all Art and Wine at Almenkerk

Peter Puts into Hermanus

Yanky Doodle Dave Didn’t Bring all the Wines

Same but Different End to the Diploma Lectures

A Cape Wine Master-class

Barrels of Fun at My First Stellenbosch Street Soirée

Lemberg Punches Above its Weight

Golden Wines at the End of the Rainbow

Super Surprises at Super Single Vineyards

Simonsig Excellence Today with a Traditional Legacy

Diploma Done and Dusted – But for the Final Result – I Passed!

Excellent Unstated Wines and Service – Naturally!

Real Wines in the Place of God

Virgin Whites Led Me into the Last Temptation

Around the (Old) World in 18 Hours – starting with the European Cuvée!


Masses of Fun and a little Chaos at the Ambeloui Harvest Festival

Back to the Future in the Berg of Paarl

Satisfaction in Getting My Ducks (and Wines) in a Row

‘Out of the Office’ at Groot Constantia

Pinotage Hits a Purple Patch in Paarl

Fish (and other foods) with Wanda!

Putting Capelands on the Cape Winelands Map!

Idiom Wines Make a Statement

High Living on the Stoep Sipping Aged, Luscious Red Wines

Judge and be Judged!

God Bless Slaley and All who Drink with Her

Wine can be so Humbling

Magnifico – Grazie Mille Idiom!

Wines to Love on Love Street

Dave Goes Down Under and the Wines Go Up

Latching onto Superb Wines at De Grendel

Wine and Food Pairing – 10 Points ©

A Myth, a Princess, History and Destruction, 2 Names and 4 Styles – Shiraz with Pizzazz

Seven Reasons To Visit Seven Oaks Wines

Swallowing Fine Wines at Paserene

Where the Lions Roar in the Wild West of Bot Rivier

1 Night, 7 Oaks, 3 Wine Tastings for Visit 2!

A Cracker and a Stormer at Paul Wallace

Rickety Tram Passengers at Rickety Bridge

On the Left, but then on the Right …

A Sparkling Tasting at Charles Fox

Superb Whites in the Near Dark at Mont Blois

Champagne and Brandies left Me Disappointed

The Early Bird Catches the Wine

Delaire Graff Wines Sparkle

Always a Favourite – Guaranteed to Delight

Cheers to Lemon Squirt Acidity and Puppy Dog Breath!

Englishman Meets Mrs English at Classic Lanzerac

Red and White Wines with Frog’s ‘Legs’

Diemersdal has Six Appeal

South over the Hills in Elgin

Superb De Trafford Worthy of Being My 200th Wine Estate

Maiden Visit to Lord’s Bowled Me Over

Excelsior Blends Quality with Price

Hout Bay Vineyards – Simply the Best!

Franschhoek’s Hidden Gem Is Reluctant to Reveal


Opening the Book at Elgin Vintners

What Is Over the Legal Limit? Some Surprising, Scary Thoughts for Tasting and Drinking

Wines Made to Stand the Taste of Time

Taking the Garage into the Classroom

The Ladies in Red


  1. Bracing Brakes on the Red Wines at Remhoogte – Cape Wine Lovers' Society

    […] sample the full range at the estate. Today offered the perfect opportunity as my Cape Wine Academy Diploma training at nearby Morgenhof finished in the early […]

  2. Around the (Old) World in 18 Hours – starting with the European Cuvée! – Cape Wine Lovers' Society

    […] classification system. Alsace, Champagne, Cognac and Armagnac followed to complete Module 1. The second Module continued the journey via Bordeaux, Burgundy, the Loire and Rhône Valleys, to the Southern Rhône, […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *