Proudly Keeping it in the Family at Paul Cluver – or Not?
Elgin Valley Experience 3.5 Wine 3.5

Proudly Keeping it in the Family at Paul Cluver – or Not?

Sunday 5 March 2017

Experience: 3.5/5
Wines: 3.5/5

I must have passed Paul Cluver wines on countless times heading East on the N2 out of Cape Town. This was an estate whose wines I had heard of but never drunk and an estate I had passed but never visited. Not only was Paul Cluver very close to Oak Valley wines but it was open for Sunday tasting too.

The sign off the N2 took me through a forest of apple bins and pallets. So much so that I thought I was heading for an industrial estate and not a wine estate. The security at the gate was some of the strictest I had experienced. My licence disc was scanned by the neatly uniformed security guard (and on my way out too). I followed the directions and was soon passing a large dam edged with water lilies. The street sign beside the road warned of ducks crossing.

The sign was fitting as Dr Paul Cluver was a visionary environmentalist. Half of the estate’s more than 2,000 hectares form part of the UNESCO World Heritage site (the Kogelberg Biosphere) which is set aside for conservation in perpetuity. As with Oak Valley wines, the remainder of the farm is put to a range of uses that do not only include wine-making: apple and pear orchards, a Hereford stud, and eco-tourism activities. The 73 hectares of vines focus on Chardonnay, Riesling and Pinot Noir.

Paul Cluver is truly a family owned and run business: Paul Jnr is Managing Director; Liesl is Marketing Director; Inge is Financial Manager and married to the winemaker; and Karin is Production Manager (orchards). This must make for some interesting Board meetings!

Passing through orchards laden with ripe red and green apples, I parked in the shade. The sign for the Tasting room, close to the restaurant, was easy to find. Outside were tables made from enormous blue gum planks. Surprisingly for a warm Sunday afternoon, the Tasting Room was empty. I introduced myself to Ismain and asked her for ‘blind’ tasting. This was free, as with the wineries in the Wolseley area, and a welcome surprise.

I asked to start with three of the five whites. Naturally, I was interested to see how these ‘cool climate’ wines compared with those from Oak Valley. My tasting radar was no better attuned. To start, I mistook an appley, stone-fruited, simple, clean Sauvignon Blanc for a Chardonnay.

Next up was my favourite wine of the tasting and also one I correctly recognised. It was the latest Gewürztraminer and full of tropical mango, melon and peach freshness with overlays of honey and nougat. The palate followed through well (this does not always happen with the more aromatic and floral-noted wines) to balance successfully. The wine was low on acidity with good dryness and mouthfeel. I read afterwards that this grape variety is grown on 10% of the estate and that Gewürztraminer is a consistent award-winner for Paul Cluver. I am not surprised.

The wine that followed was another I thought was a Chardonnay but turned out to be a Riesling. I am unsure why as their profiles are not similar: Chardonnay is fuller bodied and less fruity; Riesling is fruity and with little body. Riesling is also more acidic and with less alcohol. The tasting notes for the Riesling describe the nose showing ‘ripe green apple, apple blossom, beeswax and fynbos honey’. These are classic Chardonnay characteristics and I picked out apple and citrus notes with a little sweetness. Oddly, the mouth felt slightly fizzy but this did not show up in the appearance.

I waited for the next two wines, the last whites, before two final reds. I looked around the Tasting Room. It was well decorated and with plenty of information. The Cluver family ‘pride’, described in a separate little label on each bottle, was evident. Tasting tables indoors were made of vast cedar planks, beautifully smooth and polished like an old friend.

There was a mix up with the final two white servings. I should have tasted a Spätlese or sweeter style of Riesling and then a Chardonnay. Instead, Ismain poured the dry Riesling a second time. My notes for the repeat tasting were not identical and it just goes to show how one is influenced by the wine being tasted alongside. I preferred the sweeter wine but I have yet to get a feel for Riesling as a wine grape variety.

Weisser (‘Rhine’) Riesling, as distinct from the inferior Cape Riesling that is anonymously used in blends, is made into three wines. I did not taste the third, a dessert wine, as this was sold out. The vines have been planted from 1987 to 2006 at between 300 and 400 metres above sea level and cover 14 hectares. Paul Cluver is the largest producer of Riesling in South Africa.

My last white was a delicious, flagship Chardonnay and my equal favourite wine. Unfortunately, I did not taste it at its best as all the white wines were served too warm. This never ceases to amaze – but no longer surprises – as tasting rooms should be the perfect showcase for wines from any estate or vineyard. Rant over.

The final two reds were both of the same variety, Pinot Noir, which I identified correctly. Picked just a year apart, they were a similar pale ruby in colour. The nose reminded of aromatic maraschino cherries mingled with red cherry and strawberries. Light, fresh and fruity, the tannin did not overpower. I preferred the first. It was better value for money too at R100 compared with R200.

Paul Cluver was not as I expected. It may have been that subconsciously one associates ‘big’ wines with ‘big name’ estates. True, I am finding my feet with Riesling and Gewürztraminer (although I am familiar with their German styles from living in England). True, the tasting went wrong. True, the wines inexcusably were served at the wrong temperatures.

There was something else missing at Paul Cluver and I cannot put a finger on it. Had all the wrongs been put right, I wonder whether I would have rated the wines much higher. I did buy two wines and that would make the family proud. Overall though, I do not think the Cluver siblings would have been so proud of my tasting experience.

Wines tasted (bought *):


2016 Sauvignon Blanc – R90
2016 Gewürztraminer – R100* FAVOURITE WINE
2015 Dry Encounter Riesling – R100
2016 Close Encounter Riesling – R100
2016 Chardonnay – R200


2016 Village Pinot Noir – R100*
2015 Estate Pinot Noir – R200

You Might Also Like

A Warm Welcome in the Cool Climate at South Hill

Judge and be Judged!

Busy, Bubbly, Noisy Wonderfontein

Elgin Valley is the Cool Wine Tour

Mulderbosch didn’t quite Meet the Yardstick

Hope Brought to the Vineyard

Le Lude Left Me Feeling Flat

Style or Substance? Nitida left Me Wondering

There’s No Gun Smoke Without Wine

All Green at Villiera

A Quando-ary: When to Drink …?

View from the E-Skaap-ment

Second Helping – and Tasting – at Oak Valley

Family Fun in Pairs at Four Cousins

South over the Hills in Elgin

Late at Lateganskop

Haven Rather than Heaven at La Bri

Eq-wine – Fine Wines and Fast Horses!

Baby Thrown Out with the Bath Water?

Sylvan Vale Wines Good for a Meeting or an Eating

Scary Jan Harmsgat Delivers Elegant Wines

Libby Would not have been Proud of Linton Park

Dreaming of a Wine Christmas

All is Not Lost in a Safe Port

Dis-gorgeous at Weltevrede

Simple Spier

Try as I Could I Did not Find Waterkloof Wines Dynamic

Laibach Shows its Spots

A Kleine Experience at Zalze

2018 Wacky Wine Ends at Le Roux & Fourie

River Grandeur at Viljoensdrift

Wines That Don’t Cost The Earth

Horsepower in the Vineyard

More Plaisir at de Merle Please!

At the Bend in the Road in Bot River

Graham Beck MCCs Fizzled Out

iWine rather than IMAX at the Cape Gate Mall

Heaven and Earth Create a Costly Pairing

One Day, Three Tastings, Five Wines and Seven Sisters

Lothian Left Me Breathless – and Not Only the Wines!

Com-fort-able Wines at Fort Simon

Rijk Tulbagh Gives Name to Cellar and Town

The Cut ‘n’ Paste Stellenbosch Wine Festival Comes to Cape Town

Waterf-ord More Ord-inary Than Extra-ord-inary

Peter Falke Didn’t Knock my Socks Off

Slave to the Rhythm at Solms-Delta

Opening the Book at Elgin Vintners

Superb Views of Guardian Peak

Iona Wines Remain Excellent In and At the Vineyard

Bartinney Clings to the Mountain

Becoming Ship-Shape at La Couronne

Summer Whites …… and Rosés

Old Oaks at La Bourgogne

Kept Alone at Kaapzicht

Malverne Dis-Clos-ed

In the Highlands in the Lowlands of Elgin

Champagne and Brandies left Me Disappointed

The Vineyard Hotel a Classic Vehicle to Showcase L’Ormarins Wines

Hope Lies High in the Valley

An Early Start at Rietvallei

Verticle Tasting on the Ridge in Elgin

A Cracker and a Stormer at Paul Wallace

Surprisingly Good – and Not Only for the Red Bus Tourists

Wine Notes Composed at D’Aria

Next Time to Taste at Hannay

Hand at Work Handiwork at Boschrivier Wines

Wagons to the Cellar at Waboomsrivier

Morgenhof in the Morning

Well and Truly Oaked!

House Wine from the Wine Tram

Noble Wines without the Rot

Decent Wines Rock from the Pulpit

Honest, Affordable Family Wines at Landskroon

Relaxing Rosendal

Nala Wines are Well Engineered in the Vineyard

Sip Sip Sip and Drip Drip Drip at Domaine des Dieux

Pinotage Hits a Purple Patch in Paarl

Bracing Brakes on the Red Wines at Remhoogte

A Sparkling Tasting at Charles Fox

Yanky Doodle Dave Didn’t Bring all the Wines

Intimate, Tranquil and Refined

I-own-a Wine Farm!

Allez les Boks – Pas les Bleues!

It’s all Art and Wine at Almenkerk

Woody Wildekrans

The Italian Collection at the Vineyard

Vrede en Lust Struggled to Reveal it’s Delight

Elegant Wines Kiss the Lips in the Vineyard

Sublime Sauvignon Blanc Makes up for Variable Bloemendal

A Lekker Jol at Wandsbeck

Bushmanspad Gave Me the Weirdest Tasting Ever

Purring at the Wines in Tyger Valley

Only One JC Le Roux Wine Sparkled and Scintilla-ted

Pick n Taste Time at Stellenbosch

Wheels Turn Full ‘Cycle’ at Meerendal

Where’s the Grande in Provence?

Wines from the Orchards at Le Pommier


  1. It’s all Art and Wine at Almenkerk – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] final vineyard that I visited on my day out to the Elgin Valley having already been to Oak Valley, Paul Cluver and Charles Fox. I am always struck how individual wine farms are and the interesting story behind […]

  2. Verticle Tasting on the Ridge in Elgin – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] to visit in the Elgin Valley. I had already been to the more established and older wineries – Paul Kluver, Oak Valley, Charles Fox, Almenkirk and Iona – but not here. The 20 hectare farm was bought […]

  3. Learning about Wines with the Cape Wine Lovers is Super Cool – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] wines and their grapes, and setting the tasting table. I really enjoyed the trips to Oak Valley, Paul Cluver, Charles Fox, Almenkerk, Iona and Elgin Ridge in the Elgin Valley, together with the tastings at […]

  4. Mutual Attraction – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] Uitsig, Delheim, DeMorgenzon, Diemersdal, Glenelly, Ken Forrester, Morgenster, Oak Valley, Paul Cluver, Simonsig, and Steenberg – though did pass by to congratulate. As I read the list now, these […]

  5. Elgin Valley is the Cool Wine Tour – Cape Wine Lovers' Society

    […] beautiful wine and food Oak Valley; lovely whites Oneiric; Pinot Noir and Riesling at family estate Paul Cluver; and fun, great wines at Paul Wallace; as well as quality wines at South Hill during the past year. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *