Mutual Attraction
Experience 4.0 Festivals & Events Wine 4.5

Mutual Attraction

8 June 2017

Experience: 4/5
Wines: 4.5/5

The Old Mutual Trophy Wine Show (OMTWS) is South Africa’s premium wine competition. The 2017 edition was the 16th edition. The Judging Panel comprises 3 international and 6 local judges, with a range of expertise, and using the 100-point scoring system. They judged 960 wines from 198 producers. Awards are given as follows:

  • Trophy (T)                         highest Gold medal winner in a class
  • Gold (G)                             90 to 100 points out of 100: superlative, world class
  • Silver (S)                            80 to 89 points out of 100: excellent, wine of distinction
  • Museum Class (M)           entries at least 4 years old (white wines) and at least 8 years old (other classes)
  • Boutique (B)                      between 600 and 900 litres produced

Trophy Winners

The Awards were announced on 30 May. The coveted Trophy Winners were:

  • Most Successful Producer Overall: Tokara
  • Best Shiraz, also Best Red Wine Overall: 2014 Leeuwenkuil Heritage Syrah
  • Best Chardonnay, also Best White Wine Overall: 2016 DeMorgenzon Reserve Chardonnay
  • Discovery of the Show/Best Value Gold Medallist: 2015 Secret Cellar Merlot Malbec Cabernet Sauvignon No. 702
  • Best Cabernet Sauvignon: 2015 Landzicht Winemaker’s Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Best White Blend: 2015 Cavalli Cremello
  • Best Sparkling Wine: 2013 Constantia Uitsig Méthode Cap Classique Brut
  • Best Dessert Wine: 2014 Buitenverwachting ‘1769’
  • Best Bordeaux-Style Red Blend: 2014 Buitenverwachting Meifort
  • Best Chenin Blanc: 2016 Darling Cellars Old Bush Vines Chenin Blanc
  • Best Sauvignon Blanc: 2016 Stark-Condé Round Mountain Sauvignon Blanc
  • Best Cape Port: 2015 Boplaas Cape Vintage Reserve
  • Best Red Blend: Non-Bordeaux Style: 2015 De Krans Tritonia
  • Best Sauvignon Blanc Sémillon Blend: 2015 Tokara Director’s Reserve White
  • Best Pinotage: 2014 Bosman Family Vineyards Pinotage
  • Best Pinot Noir: 2015 Paul Wallace Brave Heart Pinot Noir
  • Best Sémillon: 2014 Deetlefs Familie White
  • Best Niche Variety: 2015 Credo Limited Release Verdelho (Stellenbosch Vineyards)
  • Best Museum Class Chenin Blanc: 2012 Kleine Zalze Family Reserve Chenin Blanc
  • Best Museum Class Chardonnay: 2009 Rustenberg Five Soldiers Chardonnay
  • Best Museum Class Unfortified Dessert Wine: 2009 Nederburg Private Bin Edelkeur Chenin Blanc Noble Late Harvest

In addition to the trophies and gold awards won, 135 silver and 460 bronze medals were awarded. Tokara was the Most Successful Producer for a 2nd time which is some achievement for a vineyard that made its first vintage in 2001. Stellenbosch is widely regarded as the heartland for fine wine and so it was interesting to learn that the Best Shiraz/Red Wine Overall and Blended Red went to vineyards outside the area: Leeuwenkuil Family Vineyards from the Swartland and De Krans from Calitzdorp, respectively.

A Trophy was awarded to a Pinot Noir for the first time in many years, to Paul Wallace Wines from Elgin. I looked forwards too to taste some of the Portuguese varietals that had won Best Non-Bordeaux Style Red Blend and Best Niche Variety.

Showcasing at the Roadshow

The Cape Town Roadshow (there’s another held in Johannesburg) was held in the CTICC. I was fortunate enough, courtesy of, to go to the Cape Town Show event and what a feast of fine wine it was. More than 100 producers – from Allée Bleue Wines to Zorgvliet Wines – filled the large, noisy conference room. Most had 1 or 2 award winning wines to taste, and a few with up to 5, to make a dazzling 171 wines on show. It was obviously impossible to taste but a fraction. I decided largely to avoid the vineyards I have visited and enjoyed – Bouchard Finlayson, Buitenverwachting, Cape Point Vineyards, Constantia Uitsig, Delheim, DeMorgenzon, Diemersdal, Glenelly, Ken Forrester, Morgenster, Oak Valley, Paul Cluver, Simonsig, and Steenberg – though did pass by to congratulate. As I read the list now, these are some of the highest scoring vineyards I have rated since starting the blog. I looked too for Arendsig, Hamilton Russell, De Wetshof, Springfield and Klein Constantia as I felt sure they would have gained medals for their amazing wines too. Curiously, they were absent.

Instead, I focused on the top award winners, lesser known vineyards, and the unusual varietals. I briefly scored each wine I tasted (using my usual 20-point criteria and 10-point ‘likeability’ assessment). This proved to be an interesting challenge in the company of fine wines so highly and, to some extent, evenly, rated. It worried me for a while that my scoring was so high and so even but then I realised this was likely to be so.

Prices interested too and were not all as expensive as I might have expected. The Paul Cluver Pinot Noir topped out at R500 but most were in the R200 price region.

I shall not describe each wine I tasted (I hear you sigh a relief) but shall focus on those I liked and scored highest. As ever, 20-point scoring has to be objective (not always easy with personal style preferences) but the 10-point ‘Likeability’ score is subjective.

Judge Peter

Peter’s ‘judging’ awarded top marks to the Cavalli Cremello, the DeMorgenzon Chardonnay and the Cabernet Sauvignon from Benguela Cove. The Cremello – incidentally, the lowest priced Trophy winner ever (R140) for Best White Blend – was a watery pale straw but with an unusual colour tinge. I couldn’t easily place it under the bright Conference Room lights but it was akin to a pale orange blush. The notes delighted. Complex honey, floral jasmine, peach, apricot, warm apple mingled to excite. It was crisp on the palate, not overly aggressive, with excellent follow through to a lingering, fresh finish.

DeMorgenzon is one of those vineyards whose wines I just know I will enjoy. I had tasted the Reserve Chardonnay before. I scored it only my second perfect 20/20 (the DMZ Chenin Blanc being my first). The warm baked apple nose melted into restrained oak that added to, rather than hid, the fruitiness in perfect harmony. My only surprise was that the Chenin Blanc was not also an award-winner. Perhaps it was not entered.

I didn’t visit Benguela Cove during my recent trips to the Hemel-en-Aarde and Elgin valleys. Benguela Cove lies between. The estate is surrounded by the Botrivier Lagoon on 2 out of 3 sides. The Cabernet Sauvignon was refined and elegant. I liked the cool climate style. Fruit and tannin balanced with delicate precision. The wine offered up a perfect trio of shiny medium ruby colour, warm, spicy fruit nose (red cherry, dark plum, mulberry with white peppercorn) and integrated, silky tannins. I would have awarded more than a Silver medal.

Other Highlights

Other white wines that stood out were from Stark-Condé. The Trophy-winning Sauvignon Blanc was the first wine that I have picked up distinctive fynbos aromas. Many wines describe fynbos flavours but I have detected few. Fynbos notes layered with sweet citrus then soft guava for an engaging nose. Follow through to the palate was exact, with a crisp mouthfeel containing fresh acidity and minerality combining for an elegant finish.

The Verdelho cultivar was new to me and a rising star among the award winners. The single variety Credo from Stellenbosch, double Trophy and Boutique winner, could have been wooded. The silky caramel flavours on the palate are from 8 months on the lees and a Chardonnay style of wine-making. Aromatic herbaceous and citrus notes gave way to fruitiness on the palate.

Verdelho was a major share (50%) of the white Tritonia blend (50% Malvasia Rei) from De Krans. The wine farm is better known as one of the leading port style producers but also for innovation. Verdelho is a Portuguese cultivar. Common in Madeira, it is used for wine of the same name. Malvasia Rei is also grown in Madeira and often used to make sherry in Portugal and Spain. The blended wine was aromatic with honeyed notes of stone fruit and tropical fruit (peach and guava). Off-dry, it melted on the palate to a soft finish.

I preferred the Trophy-winning Tritonia red, made too from grapes I had barely heard of. I had tasted a single variety Touriga Nacionale at Bergsig but not the Tinta cultivars. There were Shiraz-like similarities in the purple-tinged medium ruby colour and fruity spiciness on the nose. These aromas combined on the palate with lightweight yet firm tannins. I shall certainly make a point of visiting the Calitzdorp region and De Krans before long.

The large conference room was busy and full. Tasters appeared to me a blend of those from the industry, wine enthusiasts and casual drinkers. The signs above each stand were clear but not quite in sufficient alphabetical order easily to find a particular vineyard. Perhaps this was deliberate. I hunted out the Pinot Noir from Paul Wallace in the Elgin region, another Trophy winner. The wine offered the warm cherry aromas I prefer, mixed with strawberry and peppercorn spice. Silky not rough on the palate, I liked the follow through and soft elegance of tannin with fruitiness.

Fable Mountain Vineyards from Tulbach is famed for its Rhône varieties. The unfined and unfiltered Syrah, made in classic European-style, was a winner for me as well as a Gold medal holder. It was everything I liked about the cultivar. Lighter in body than some Shiraz (and I use that word deliberately), it had classic ruby-purple colour; dark berry-plum and chilli-peppercorn notes that perfectly balanced; and a palate that invited more. Spicy on entry, rounded acidity and persistent tannins held on for a refined finish.

Light snacks and food were on offer but I did not buy as I wanted to use my time to sample the many superb wines on show. I noticed 2 interesting displays with bowls and jars containing fruit, spices and other examples of the principal aromas and flavours found in wine. The displays appeared to be little noticed but obvious thought had been put into them. Note cards giving simple characteristics of each varietal were equally useful.

Mutual Benefits

This was my first OMTWS and a delight to attend. I reflected on the vibrancy, creativity and inventiveness of the South African wine industry. Trophy and Gold winners are adjudged to be World class. The sheer hard work and commitment, investment included, by the owners and winemakers (judges too) was as impressive as humbling. I noticed too trends that I have picked up elsewhere on my tasting visits to over 60 vineyards, of which I shall write more soon. I don’t recall having tasted one heavily wooded wine, for example. I am sure there were some but they were very much in the small minority. Terroir-driven, mineral rich, elegant wines are the new fashion. I was fascinated too to see and taste the Portuguese cultivars that typically are used for port and fortified wines.

I could easily have stayed for long after show closing time. I shall certainly plan to attend next year. The benefit and the attraction were truly Mutual!

Wines tasted (* bought):


S              2012 Cederberg Blanc de Blancs (Chardonnay) Brut MCC Classique – R160


TB          2015 Stellenbosch Vineyards Credo Limited Release Verdelho – R250
T             2015 Cavalli Cremello (42% Chenin Blanc, 31% Chardonnay, 27% Verdelho) – R140
T             2014 Deetlefs Famille White (90% Sémillon, 10% Sauvignon Blanc) – R295
T             2016 DeMorgenzon Reserve Chardonnay – R354
T             2016 Stark-Condé Mountain Reserve Sauvignon Blanc – R175
T             2015 Tokara Director’s Reserve White (71% Sauvignon Blanc, 29% Sémillon) – R245
G             2016 King Kloof Sauvignon Blanc – R75
G             2016 Marianne Sauvignon Blanc – R175
S              2015 De Krans Tritonia White (50% Malvasia Rei, 50% Verdelho) – R180


TB          2015 Landzicht Winemaker’s Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon – R140
T             2015 De Krans Tritonia Red (67 % Touriga Nacionale, 22% Tinta Barocca, 6% Tinta Roriz, 5% Tinta Amarela) – R180
T             2014 Leeuwenkuil Heritage Syrah – R300
T             2015 Paul Wallace Brave Heart Pinot Noir – R185
G             2014 Fable Mountain Vineyards Syrah – R375
G             2015 Paul Cluver Seven Flags Pinot Noir – R500
S              2014 Benguela Cove Cabernet Sauvignon – R180


  1. Wine Passions Mounted at Cavalli – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] unusual blend was the Cremello. I had tasted it before at the Old Mutual Trophy Wine Show where it won the Trophy for the Best White Blend. Not only that but it was the lowest priced Trophy […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *