Heaven and Earth Create a Costly Pairing
Experience 3.5 Hemel-en-Aarde Valley Wine 3.0

Heaven and Earth Create a Costly Pairing

Saturday 6 May 2017

Experience: 3.5/5
Wines: 3/5

The words ‘wine’, ‘creation’, ‘heaven’ and ‘earth’ seamlessly blended together into a complete sentence as I made my way from tastings at Hamilton Russell and Bouchard Finlayson to the top of the Hemel-en-Aarde (Afrikaans for ‘Heaven and Earth’) valley above Walker Bay. Creation Wines was to be the highest vineyard in the valley I would visit today, yet shared the same entrance sign off the R320 as Mount Babylon and Jacob’s vineyards.

The modern Tasting Room and Restaurant were visible from afar as I followed the winding road into the farm. On arrival, I was asked whether I had made a booking. It was lunchtime and the room was noisy and packed. Creation was obviously the place to go with friends on a Saturday. Fortunately, I did not have to wait long and I ordered a cheese platter (R170). Phillip was my host.

Service was quick and Phillip attentive (too much so) despite the busy atmosphere. As I sampled the very young Sauvignon Blanc – the first of the 2017 vintage and bottled just 2 days previously, as 2016 supplies were sold out – the cheese platter arrived. I hadn’t looked at the menu, just asked for a cheese platter, and so somewhat surprised to see a prettily-decorated board ready for wine pairing. Each of the 4 elements contained: a bread, bread stick or equivalent; a cheese; an edible flower or herb; and a pickle or jam.

Meanwhile, the cool climate Sauvignon Blanc was showing its offensive youth by being pungent, pushy and with a range of forward smells, notably of grass and zesty citrus fruits. The Viognier that followed, to match the curried breadsticks, mild cheese, snapdragon flower and apricot jam, was better. It too was big on the nose but with broader complexity. Floral, violet and jasmine aromas mingled with those of white peach and apricots. The balance on the palate too, with slight oiliness but less than the Viognier I have tasted closer to home at Eagles’ Nest, was better.

My favourite wine was a lightly wooded Chardonnay that was served in a Montrachet (large balloon-shaped) glass. The design is aimed to bring the wine to the sides of the mouth (narrow, tall glasses focus wine to the back of the mouth) where the sour and salty taste buds are. The oak maturation (8 months, 30% in new and 70% in 2nd/3rd fill French oak) showed in a deeper, medium straw, colour than the first 2 wines. The mouth feel was smoother and creamier, with a lingering finish, which picked up the notes of caramel, honey, stewed apples and pear from the nose.

There was little time to evaluate the wines before Phillip returned with the red wines to taste. A full restaurant perhaps needs to hurry its guests up but the service was too rushed fully to savour, relax and enjoy. The Merlot was classic in character and of average quality. Wood, cedar and cigar aromas were distinguishable from those of plum and dark cherry. The grippy tannins were persistent but dull in the finish. It fared better than the Syrah-Grenache blend that followed. The medium ruby to medium purple colour, together with simple white peppercorn spice and dark fruit on the nose, promised better than the palate. The woody tannins were too aggressive, barely allowing the spice to follow-through, and unbalanced.

I bought a bottle of the Pinot Noir (I needed a Hermanus red for the Society tasting of wines from Elgin and Hermanus on 18 May). This too was served in a Montrachet glass and scored better in my assessment. It looked an attractive light-bodied, deep pink in the glass which focused the red cherry, redcurrant, strawberry and raspberry aromas to my nose. The tannins were more integrated to give crispness rather than hardness and a fresh finish.

I wondered on leaving if I would have enjoyed the experience (and perhaps the wines too) if I had visited at a quieter time of the week. Saturday is a busy time, booking always advisable I was told, and not best for a wine tasting. The food was certainly imaginatively and creatively prepared and for pairing with the Creation wines, of that there was no doubt. The chefs offer a dazzling array of pairings: cheese, tapas, brunch, chocolate, non-alcoholic (teas), kid’s surprise, and 3-course lunch. Phew! I was reminded by my recent tasting at Clos Malverne, where restaurant and tasting room were similarly combined and with a like focus on the food, and to the detriment of the wine tasting experience.

Creation Wines is a young vineyard. It has achieved much since Swiss-born Jean-Claude and Carolyn Martin (intriguingly née Finlayson, I wonder if related to Peter Finlayson at Bouchard Finlayson vineyard lower down the valley) took on the immense task in 2002 of establishing a virgin vineyard from 40 hectares of undulating pasture on the Hemel-en-Aarde Ridge. I felt an associated sense of urgency from youth during my visit that translated into the fresh, acidic wines.

To end, Creation Wines is ideally suited as a place for the diner to go for fancy food-with-wines at the weekend. I am sure it attracts many of the well-to-do from Hermanus, Betty’s Bay, Caledon, Franschhoek and further afield. On the other hand if, on a Saturday morning, you’re a drinker who seeks wines-with-food and better value for money wines (Creation was expensive and can afford to be, such is the demand) then stop off at Bouchard Finlayson or Hamilton Russell (or both) lower down the Hemel-en-Aarde Valley.

Wines tasted (bought *):


2017 Sauvignon Blanc – R115
2016 Viognier – R125
2016 Chardonnay – R185 FAVOURITE WINE


2015 Merlot – R190
2015 Syrah-Grenache (80% Syrah, 20% Grenache) – R190
2016 Pinot Noir – R210*

You Might Also Like

Heaven Meets Earth at Bouchard Finlayson

Pick n Taste Time at Stellenbosch

Graham Beck MCCs Fizzled Out

Champagne and Brandies left Me Disappointed

Robertson – Town by Name, Wine by Name

Nala Wines are Well Engineered in the Vineyard

The Italian Collection at the Vineyard

Allez les Boks – Pas les Bleues!

Intimate, Tranquil and Refined

Dornier Disappoints

Try as I Could I Did not Find Waterkloof Wines Dynamic

River Grandeur at Viljoensdrift

Late at Lateganskop

Baby Thrown Out with the Bath Water?

The Gods Come Home to the Vineyard

Malverne Dis-Clos-ed

All is Not Lost in a Safe Port

A Quando-ary: When to Drink …?

In the Highlands in the Lowlands of Elgin

Wines That Don’t Cost The Earth

Virgin Whites Led Me into the Last Temptation

Eq-wine – Fine Wines and Fast Horses!

Mulderbosch didn’t quite Meet the Yardstick

Woody Wildekrans

Wheels Turn Full ‘Cycle’ at Meerendal

Dis-gorgeous at Weltevrede

Hand at Work Handiwork at Boschrivier Wines

Quantity over Quality at Durbanville Hills

Wonderful Grapes at the Vineyard Hotel

There’s No Gun Smoke Without Wine

At the Bend in the Road in Bot River

Swiss Family Sauvignons at Eikendal

Proudly Keeping it in the Family at Paul Cluver – or Not?

Kept Alone at Kaapzicht

Next Time to Taste at Hannay

Elegant Wines Kiss the Lips in the Vineyard

“Swimming Pool” Wines for Now – or Leave until Later

House Wine from the Wine Tram

Mixed Spice at the Pinotage Festival

The Vineyard Hotel a Classic Vehicle to Showcase L’Ormarins Wines

Wine Notes Composed at D’Aria

Never too Early in the Morning for Wine Tasting!

Decent Wines Rock from the Pulpit

Two Dam Good!

Intriguing and Confusing – An Enigmatic Experience

Rijk Tulbagh Gives Name to Cellar and Town

Good Things Come in Twos – at Southern Right too!

Hope Brought to the Vineyard

Horsepower in the Vineyard

Style or Substance? Nitida left Me Wondering

Serenity without Worry or Preoccupation in the Chapel

Haven Rather than Heaven at La Bri

Noble Wines without the Rot

British Reserve and Excellence at Sumaridge

Judge and be Judged!


  1. Serenity without Worry or Preoccupation in the Chapel – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] ‘chapel’ was easily visible from the R320 as I headed south from Creation Wines. The proximity was deceptive as the approach drive wended its way though forest and vineyard. The […]

  2. British Reserve and Excellence at Sumaridge – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] spoke for themselves without the need for flashy food pairing or witty labels that characterise Creation Wines and La Vierge, above and below in the Valley. British reserve – and windy British weather […]

  3. Learning about Wines with the Cape Wine Lovers is Super Cool – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] at Southern Right, Hamilton Russell, Bouchard Finlayson, La Vierge, Sumaridge, Ataraxia and Creation in the Hemel-en-Aarde Valley. There’s more to visit too and I shall […]

  4. Slave to the Rhythm at Solms-Delta – Cape Wine Lovers Society

    […] afterwards. Solms-Delta was one of those occasions. Visits to Constantia Uitsig, Meerendal, Creation, Quando and Ataraxia also come to mind. Solms-Delta is picked out from the hundreds of Western Cape […]

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *